The One I Love

Mark Duplass

Ethan

Elisabeth Moss

Sophie

Ted Danson

Therapist

Kiana Cason

Waitress

Kaitlyn Dodson

Diner Patron

Lori Farrar

Diner Patron

Marlene Malin

Diner Patron

Tim Peddicord

Diner Patron

Ryan Pederson

Diner Patron

Brett Bietz

Doug (voice)

Sean O'Malley

Dave (voice)

Mary Steenburgen

Mom (voice)

Drew Langer

Brett (voice)

Jennifer Spriggs

Ellen (voice)

Charlie McDowell

Madison (voice)

Mel Eslyn

Victoria (voice)

Jeremy Mackie

Other Male (voice)

Liz Lash

Other Female (voice)